Podcast episode 225 featured image.

Listen Now

EPISODE: 225 – The People Problem You’re Probably Missing

Most shop owners know they have a people problem when someone is clearly toxic, can’t do the job, or just isn’t a good fit. But what if your biggest people problem is the person you never have to worry about?

You know the one. They show up, do their job, live your core values, get results, and rarely need your attention. They’re your “Steady Eddie.” And because they’re doing so well, you may be giving them less attention than everyone else on your team.

That can be a dangerous mistake.

In this episode of the Auto Repair Marketing Podcast, Brian and Kim Walker break down the four types of people problems every shop owner needs to recognize: the wrong person in the wrong seat, the wrong person in the right seat, the right person in the wrong seat, and the surprisingly overlooked right person in the right seat.

They talk about why high-performing employees still need leadership, appreciation, feedback, training, and opportunities to grow and how neglecting your best people can eventually send them looking for a shop that appreciates them more.

If you want to build a team that sticks around, grows with your business, and helps you build the shop you actually want to own, this is an episode you’ll want to hear.

Listen to the full episode and find out whether you’re taking care of your “Steady Eddies” before someone else does.

Speaker 1 00:00:00  This is the Automotive Repair Podcast Network.

Brian Walker 00:00:09  Hi everyone, and welcome to another episode of the Auto Repair Marketing Podcast. I'm your host, Brian Walker, and today my co-host is finally Kim again. We're back recording together, and we've got an interesting topic today that is about the people problem that you may not even know that you have something that could be looming around the corner if you're not careful. But before we get too far into that, let's take a second to thank our sponsors. Declined repairs don't have to be lost. Revenue at fields call center schedules, follow up calls, and equips your team with everything they need to close the deal. Get started now at appfueled.com. Hey, Kim.

Kim 00:00:51  Hey, Brian.

Brian Walker 00:00:52  All right, so we were just at ASTA and we were having a conversation with our friends John Firm and Jeff Compton and this idea of this people problem. You brought it up and you blew their minds. And it was like, man, we should record about this. Tell us about this thing.

Speaker 4 00:01:10  Yeah.

Kim 00:01:10  So a lot of people know we are an EOS company, entrepreneurial operating system. And so it's important to say that because what I'm about to open with is part of EOS. And in the people aspect of EOS, and I live in the HR world. We learned, I think, from our implementers sometime over the last five years about the four different types of people problems, and I always screw these up, but I have them written down, so I'm going to say them correctly. One people problem is right person, right seat. This is the person who fits your values and they can do the job. And maybe not only can do the job, but they're like killing it in the job. The second one is the right person but in the wrong seat. They're a great cultural fit, but you've got them in the wrong roll, the wrong position, the wrong job. The third one is the wrong person in the right seat. They're capable at their job, but they don't align with your core values.

Kim 00:02:12  And then finally, the fourth one is the wrong person in the wrong seat. They're the wrong fit all the way around. In EOS terms, the right person is primarily about your core values, while the right seat is about whether an EOS we call it GWC. They get it, they want it, and they have the capacity to do it. So we're just going to kind of briefly break down each one of these seats. I know that when we were in that podcast recording, I asked John and Jeff which of those four people problems do you think is your biggest people problem or the obvious? And they both said, right person, wrong seat, which I think a lot of people say that or a lot of people say the super obvious, which is wrong person, wrong seat. But what you're getting at, Brian, is that I told them I gave them a different perspective. And I don't know that it's necessarily like you can rank them like this is the worst people problem, but probably the best word choice is the most overlooked people problem.

Brian Walker 00:03:22  Yeah. Because when you said it, you said there's four types of people problem. Saying you're like right person, right seat. And like, well, how is that a problem?

Kim 00:03:30  Well, we're going to get to that. I want to kind of go in a different order and kind of end with that one, because I think, I mean, we kind of just laid it out there. That's the one that really blew their minds. And so I think saving the best for last, I just want to kind of hold that till the end. So I think if we talk about each of the other three, the other, the final one will just really wrap it all up. So let's talk about the wrong person in the wrong seat. It's obvious.

Brian Walker 00:04:04  Yeah. I mean, those are the ones where it's like, you probably should have fired them months ago if you've gotten that far in. They don't fit the culture. They don't do their job well. Like, they just. I'll just say they're just bad.

Brian Walker 00:04:18  They're just bad in every way.

Kim 00:04:21  I mean, they might be right for someone else, but it all depends on your core values, who you are as a company, what you're expecting. And so still, even when it's the wrong person, the wrong seat. Too many people put that off, but you got to address it. Just make the decisions. Stop allowing one bad fit to drain your whole team, and you got to part ways and move on, right. So we can agree that one's pretty straightforward. So the next one is the wrong person. But they're in the right seat. Now Brian, you and I have had this person in the past. They're dangerous because they're great.

Brian Walker 00:05:00  They're good at what they do.

Kim 00:05:02  Yes.

Brian Walker 00:05:03  Yeah. They're good. You know. So in the world of an auto repair shop like this is a technician that can fix anything. They don't have comebacks or fast. They make you lots of hours.

Kim 00:05:12  Yeah. And people want to keep them. Or maybe you don't realize.

Kim 00:05:17  Like, for us, I think for a while, we didn't realize this person. This is the toxic person. Right. We didn't realize that in front of us. They seemed like they were super hero. But as soon as we left and were out of sight, out of mine, they were just stirring the pot, creating drama. You know, and I think that this is where, to your point, what you said just a second ago, if we're looking at a shop technician, for example, the shop owner might be look how many hours they turn. They're so fast.

Brian Walker 00:05:53  Well, you think that they're making you money, but what you don't understand is what they're doing to the rest of your team. That one person there, over there, they're turning the hours, they're fixing the cars, but they've got 5 or 6 other people that they're making miserable in their work. And I've talked to shop owners before that when they finally got rid of that person, the rest of their team, like stood up and they made up for what was missed with that person.

Brian Walker 00:06:24  And it's so hard to do because today, you know, we talk about the technician shortage. And then even when you find technicians, it's like, are they that really good a tech or even that really good BTec because most shops would kill to have the really good B.Tech for sure.

Kim 00:06:41  But we've had team members in the past where we finally came to the light and realized and parted ways with that person. So in years past when we fired them and we've had team members come and say, I can't believe it took you so long. And we're like, I can't believe you didn't tell me. But then, you know, we didn't have our core values, like really fine tuned and really practicing them. And now I believe that our core values push the wrong person out. They realize they don't want to be here because the core values aligned. So on one hand, I'm saying it's going to push them out. But you know, you just said with the technician shortage and how difficult it is to find, what do you think about how do you approach this? What do you do?

Brian Walker 00:07:31  Yeah.

Brian Walker 00:07:31  Well, I mean, if you truly have a set of core values that you actually use are not just decorations for your wall, then it doesn't give you another option like when it comes to your core values, is what I mean. The name defines them. They are your values at your core. So when you have somebody who doesn't fit, they have to go. Period.

Kim 00:07:51  Are you giving them a chance? Are you trying to coach them on the values or I believe performance does not excuse their behavior.

Brian Walker 00:08:00  Absolutely. Yeah. I mean, you're definitely going to give the person an opportunity to make it right. And that starts by having a conversation to let them know what they're doing wrong. You know, quickly when that a lot of times, you know, before you even give them the chance whether or not they're going to be able to turn it. But you still need to give them the opportunity to change.

Kim 00:08:19  So we agree that in the wrong person, right seat, we're going to coach them.

Kim 00:08:25  We're going to give them an opportunity. But when you know and you know, you know, we're going to part ways.

Brian Walker 00:08:31  Yeah. And also it depends on the level of toxicity that they bring. Because look if they're like ridiculously toxic they just gotta go.

Kim 00:08:39  Okay. So the next one is right person wrong seat. We're not going to throw away a good person. Now here at Shop Marketing Pros we use the Tony Robbins DISC profile. And now we're using another tool from within the EOS tool of tools or the toolbox tool, whatever you want to call it is the Six Working Genius. And it's really opening some eyes and helping us to see things. But the right person, they align with your core values. We just got them in the wrong seat. They love your shop, they love your core values. They love who you are. But something about the job just isn't clicking. What do you think about that one?

Brian Walker 00:09:20  Yeah. So I mean, that could be the person who is the technician that they constantly have comebacks, they can't figure it out.

Brian Walker 00:09:28  I've worked with these people before. When I was a dealer tech, they would always put the new technicians with me to mentor them. And we had the guys that were fresh out of Mercedes school, and there were some of them that like they were just natural born technicians. And then there were some of them where it was like, I don't know if they're ever going to get it. You know, they're the people that they can't hold their wrench, you know, without dropping it or, you know, everything they touch just it messes up. But that person. They might make a great service advisor. They might make a great parts person or something like that. It's just that they either they don't have it in them to be a technician, or you don't have it in you to wait out their learning period while they're messing things up. But great human being, they fit the culture well. They're just not good at the job that you hired them to do. Independent auto repair shops. Get ready to transform your business with AppFueled.

Brian Walker 00:10:30  It's time for your professional auto service shop to have its own customer loyalty app. AppFueled will build an app that launches a custom loyalty program for your shop in 30 days or less, fully integrated with your point of sale system. Bring fortune 500 level customer retention strategies to your business without the fortune 500 budget. Many shops are enjoying the benefits. Our app engages your customers with a loyalty ladder, enticing them to climb the next rung, coming back more often and spending more each visit, all with your own app. Build loyalty with your customers to your brand and boost your shop's growth. Get your first app in 30 days or less, all without breaking the bank. Ready to start? Let app fueled. Take your business to the next level. Go to appfueled.com or meet founder Jeremy Glasco and book your complimentary app vision session at appfueled.com. Jeremy. That's appfueled, and Jeremy.

Kim 00:11:29  Well, I think that as business owners, we have a responsibility to really invest in this person and try to get on the right seat for them if you have it.

Kim 00:11:40  We're not talking about inventing a new seat, but I think that you have to look up and you have to look down because the perfect fit for them might be maybe in a role that's a little more elevated. Or it could be that they need to take a step back. And so for us, like we use the Tony Robbins DISC, it's a free tool. It's really amazing. We've used it for years. It can help you to understand their behavioral tendencies, their communication style, their personality. It's more of a personality assessment. The six working genius really gets more practical to how they work and what they naturally enjoy and contribute to, and what types of tasks may be very frustrating to them. Before deciding that they have failed, ask whether the seat is failing them. Here's some questions that I pulled together for those who are listening. If you have that person you just love, they're great for your company, but they're just not doing great in that specific job. Ask, is this person wired for this kind of work? Are we asking them to spend all day working in frustration? Is there another seat where they could thrive? So those are some things you can think about before you make a decision on what you're going to do with them.

Kim 00:12:56  Okay. So this is the one, right? This is the one where we're waiting to get to. So when John and Jeff and Brian and I were talking about this and they said that they thought the biggest people problem was having the right person in the wrong seat, the one we were just talking about. In that case, I just spent more time talking about what to do with them. Like, you love them, you care about them, they're great. You're going to invest in them. You're going to take time. Flip that around. What I really believe is the most I said the biggest people problem, but that really makes it think like you're rating it. But the most overlooked people problem is the right person in the right seat. And I think that it was Jeff that said, you're steady Eddie. He kind of gave him a name. That's the one. They're they're great. They're dependable. They live your core values. They get results. And so when you have. Steady, Eddy.

Kim 00:14:01  Brian, what are you doing with steady, Eddy?

Brian Walker 00:14:03  You do nothing. And that's the problem. You ignore. Steady, Eddy. Steady. Eddy is over there doing a great job for you. And he's watching you spend all of this time with the other people because you know they're not as good at what they do. And you're over there trying to make them better. And you're doing absolutely nothing for steady, Eddy. You're doing nothing to make Steady Eddy a better, well technician or service advisor or whatever position they feel for you, that you're doing nothing to make him feel appreciated. It's so easy to do that because, I mean, running a business is hard, and you tend to. You focus all your time on the problems and you don't focus on the stuff that's going well. And I actually do think that this could be the biggest people problem. And the reason why is when you lose somebody like that, how big of an impact does that make on your business? It's immeasurable.

Kim 00:14:59  Oh my gosh.

Kim 00:15:00  Well, and just think, your customers probably get to love them because they fit. Your core values are probably personable. They're probably the ripple effect is huge, but they're watching you invest, spend time, send to training. Maybe you're taking them to lunch, the right person in the wrong seat, and they're sitting over here going, he doesn't take me to lunch. He's not sending me to training. I'm a lifelong learner. I don't ever want to stop learning. They're unfortunately watering that seed of I feel unappreciated. I feel pushed to the side I feel forgotten about. And the whole time you think they're great. And meanwhile, some other shop right down the street who's desperate for a great technician, is posting on their social media About their team going to training and their bright lit up shop and all this great stuff, and they see great reviews. And before you know it, that other shop is watering the seed of doubt that's in your a player's mind, and suddenly they're applying and you walk in to the worst day of the year when your right person right seat quits.

Brian Walker 00:16:17  So how do you keep that from happening?

Kim 00:16:19  Well, one, I think that you have to recognize that your best people still need you. They still need you to lead them. They still deserve your time and your attention. They still deserve to know that they're important, that they need feedback. They need development. They might need new challenges. They're looking to expand and to grow. They're looking for someone to ask, what do you want? They need appreciation before another company decides to appreciate them for you. Don't let someone else's ability to work without your help become a reason. They have to work without your attention. One thing I would say is, and we're actually working on incorporating this, I've been working on our SMP people playbook and I am going to be incorporating a stay interview. Ask them, take them out to lunch, spend some time with them, and ask what's making your job harder than it needs to be? Are we leaning on you too much to cover for others? What would you like to learn or do next? What do you want? What are you looking forward to? And ask them, what could I do that would make you want to stay here? Or better yet, ask, are you still happy here? So I think that it's important to know that those people need to be kept grown, celebrated, and they have to be given the opportunity to stretch.

Kim 00:17:44  And this is something I'm sharing with our team. Retention does not belong to HR. It belongs to everyone on the team. It's not just about fixing unhappy employees. Retention is continuing to recruit the people who already work for you. You know, in marriage, what do they say? Keep dating. Well, keep hiring your current team members.

Brian Walker 00:18:10  All right. Well. Thanks, Kim. Hope that you all enjoyed this episode of the Auto Repair Marketing Podcast. Remember, we are one of a handful of podcasts on the Automotive Repair Podcast Network. You can find the others at AutomotiveRepairPodcastNetwork.com. I hope that you'll listen in again next week. And until then, go fill those bays.

Speaker 1 00:18:28  You've been listening to the Auto Repair Marketing podcast with Kim and Brian Walker on the Automotive Repair Podcast Network. Download our exclusive podcast app at AutomotiveRepairPodcastNetwork.Com because the best conversations in the industry start here. Marketing questions? Well, the Walkers have the answers. Check the show notes for their email.

Timestamps

Introduction and sponsor message (00:00:00) Brian welcomes listeners, introduces the episode’s people-problem topic, and thanks sponsor AppFueled.

The four people problems (00:01:10) Kim explains the right-person/right-seat framework and how values and job fit determine each category.

Wrong person, wrong seat (00:03:30) They discuss addressing an obvious mismatch instead of letting one poor fit drain the team.

Wrong person, right seat (00:04:21) They describe capable but toxic employees, whose negative influence can outweigh their strong performance.

Coaching or parting ways (00:06:41) They discuss using core values, giving employees a chance to improve, and acting when toxicity persists.

Right person, wrong seat (00:08:39) They explore how personality and working-style tools can help identify a role better suited to a valued employee.

AppFueled advertisement (00:10:30) Brian promotes a custom loyalty app designed to improve customer retention and shop growth.

Supporting employees in the wrong role (00:11:29) Kim suggests assessing whether an employee is suited to their work and considering other available roles.

Right person, right seat: the overlooked problem (00:12:56) They introduce dependable, high-performing employees who are often overlooked because they require little attention.

Recognizing and retaining steady performers (00:14:01) Brian and Kim explain how neglecting appreciation, development, and attention can lead valued employees to leave.

Stay interviews and ongoing retention (00:16:17) Kim recommends asking employees what they need, supporting their growth, and treating retention as everyone’s responsibility.

Closing remarks (00:18:10) Brian thanks listeners, points them to the podcast network, and signs off.

How To Get In Touch

Lagniappe (Books, Links, Other Podcasts, etc)

THIS PODCAST HAS BEEN MADE POSSIBLE BY

Shop Marketing Pros branded green and blue logo
Looking for something?
Let’s help you find it!
Filter by Categories
Skip to content