TL;DR: EOS sorts every people problem into four combinations: right person, right seat; right person, wrong seat; wrong person, right seat; and wrong person, wrong seat. Most shop owners can name the obvious ones, like the toxic tech who’s great at the job or the great culture fit stuck in the wrong role. The most overlooked one is the person doing everything right. They live your core values, they get results, and they get almost none of your attention. Ignore them long enough, and another shop will happily give them the appreciation you didn’t.
Picture a normal week in your shop. You’re taking the tech with all the comebacks to lunch. You’re paying for his training. You’re coaching him through every mistake. Your best person is in the next bay, watching all of it.
Down the street, a shop that’s desperate for good help is posting about their team going to training, their bright, lit-up shop, their great reviews. Your best person sees those posts too. One day they walk in and give notice, and it’s the worst day of your year.
Nobody saw it coming, because nobody was looking. That’s the people problem most shop owners miss.
The Four People Problems Every Shop Has
Shop Marketing Pros runs on EOS, the Entrepreneurial Operating System, and one of the most useful tools in it is a simple way to look at your people. Every team member gets measured against two questions.
Are they the right person? That’s about your core values. Do they live them, or just tolerate them?
Are they in the right seat? EOS calls this GWC: they get it, they want it, and they have the capacity to do it.
Put those two questions together and you get four combinations:
- Right person, right seat
- Right person, wrong seat
- Wrong person, right seat
- Wrong person, wrong seat
Ask a lot of shop owners which one is their biggest problem, and they’ll say right person, wrong seat. Or they’ll pick the obvious one, wrong person, wrong seat. Both are real issues, but neither is the most damaging one that can sneak up on you.
Wrong Person, Wrong Seat: Make the Call
This is the employee who doesn’t fit your culture and can’t do the job. Wrong fit all the way around.
They might still be right for someone else. It all depends on your core values, who you are as a company, and what you expect. They’re just not right for yours.
If someone like this is on your team right now, you probably should have let them go months ago. Too many owners keep putting it off. Stop allowing one bad fit to drain your whole team. Make the decision, part ways, and move on.
Wrong Person, Right Seat: The Dangerous One
This one’s harder, because they’re good at the job.
In an auto repair shop, this is usually the technician who can fix anything. No comebacks. Fast. Turns a ton of hours. On paper, they’re your superhero.
Brian and I have had this person on our team. In front of us, they looked like a star. As soon as we were out of sight, they were stirring the pot and creating drama.
That’s what makes this person so expensive. You think they’re making you money because of the hours on the board. What you don’t see is the five or six other people they’re making miserable along the way.
Shop owners who finally let this person go often find out the same thing: the rest of the team stands up and covers what was missing. When we parted ways with ours, team members told us, “I can’t believe it took you so long.” The only honest answer was, “I can’t believe you didn’t tell me.”
Coach First, Unless the Toxicity Is Extreme
Performance doesn’t excuse behavior. Still, most people deserve a chance to fix it. Start with a conversation. Tell them exactly what they’re doing wrong and give them a real opportunity to change. Usually you’ll know pretty quickly whether they can turn it around, and when you know, you know.
The exception is the level of toxicity. If someone is ridiculously toxic, skip the coaching. They need to go.
The technician shortage is real, and most shops would kill to have a really good B tech, let alone an A tech. That’s exactly why this decision feels so hard. If your core values are something you use, not decorations for your wall, they don’t leave you another option. They’re the values at the core of your shop. Someone who doesn’t fit them has to go, period.
When your values are clearly defined and practiced every day, they start doing some of this work for you. The wrong person feels it. They don’t want to stay somewhere that runs on values they don’t share, and they push themselves out.
Right Person, Wrong Seat: Before You Decide They Failed
This is the team member who loves your shop and lives your core values, but something about the job just isn’t clicking.
It might be the technician who keeps having comebacks, or who can’t seem to figure it out. Brian saw plenty of this as a dealer tech, when new hires fresh out of Mercedes school were paired with him for mentoring. Some were natural-born technicians. Others couldn’t hold a wrench without dropping it, and everything they touched seemed to go wrong.
Those people weren’t bad hires. Some of them would make a great service advisor or parts person. Either they weren’t built to be technicians, or the shop didn’t have it in them to wait out the learning period.
Shop owners have a responsibility here. A great culture fit is too valuable to throw away. That doesn’t mean inventing a new job. It means looking up and looking down at the seats you already have. The right fit might be a role that’s a little more elevated. It might mean taking a step back.
Before deciding they’ve failed, ask whether the seat is failing them:
- Is this person wired for this kind of work?
- Are we asking them to spend all day working in frustration?
- Is there another seat where they could thrive?
Use Tools Instead of Guessing
At SMP, we’ve used the Tony Robbins DISC profile for years. It’s free, and it shows a person’s behavioral tendencies, communication style, and personality. More recently, we added the Six Working Genius. It gets more practical about how someone works, what they naturally enjoy and contribute, and which kinds of tasks frustrate them. It’s opening a lot of eyes on our team.
Together, they turn “this isn’t working” into a real conversation about where someone fits.
Right Person, Right Seat: The Most Overlooked People Problem
This sounds like the goal, not a problem. It is the goal. That’s why it gets ignored.
This is the person who lives your core values, gets results, and never gives you a reason to worry. Jeff Compton, a friend in the industry, gave this person a name: Steady Eddie.
So what do most shop owners do with Steady Eddie?
Nothing. That’s the problem.
Running a shop is hard, and problems demand your attention. The struggling tech gets your lunch hour, the training budget, and the coaching. Steady Eddie gets left alone because he’s “fine.” Nobody’s doing anything to make him better at his job, and nobody’s doing anything to make him feel appreciated.
He notices. He might be a lifelong learner who never wants to stop growing, and he’s watching someone else get sent to training while he isn’t. Every lunch he’s not invited to waters a seed: I feel unappreciated. I feel pushed to the side. I feel forgotten.
The whole time, you think he’s great. You just never showed him.
That’s when the shop down the street starts showing up in his feed. Team training. A bright, lit-up shop. Great reviews. Now another shop is watering a seed of doubt in your A player’s mind, and before long, he’s applying.
The impact of losing that person is close to immeasurable. Your customers have probably grown to love them, because people who live your values tend to take care of people. The ripple effect on your team and your customers is huge.
How to Keep Steady Eddie
Your best people still need you. They still deserve your time, your attention, and your leadership. They need feedback and development. They might need new challenges, because they’re looking to expand and grow.
Most of all, they need appreciation before another company decides to appreciate them for you.
Don’t let someone else’s ability to work without your help become a reason they have to work without your attention.
Start Doing Stay Interviews
We’re working on adding stay interviews to our SMP People Playbook. The idea is simple. Take your best people out to lunch, spend real time with them, and ask questions like these:
- What’s making your job harder than it needs to be?
- Are we leaning on you too much to cover for others?
- What would you like to learn or do next?
- What do you want?
- What are you looking forward to?
- What could I do that would make you want to stay here?
Or ask the simplest version: Are you still happy here?
The answers show you how to keep, grow, and celebrate the people you can’t afford to lose, and where to give them room to stretch.
Retention Belongs to Everyone
Retention doesn’t belong to HR. It belongs to everyone on the team. It’s not only about fixing unhappy employees, either. Retention is continuing to recruit the people who already work for you.
There’s an old piece of marriage advice: keep dating. Same idea here. Keep hiring your current team members.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does "right person, right seat" mean in EOS?
What should I do with a technician who's great at the job but toxic to the team?
How do I know if someone is the right person in the wrong seat?
What is a stay interview?
Why do great employees leave without warning?
Your Best People Deserve the Same Attention as Your Marketing
Shop Marketing Pros spends most of its time talking with shop owners about auto repair shop marketing: more calls, more cars, more reviews. The shops that get the most out of marketing for auto repair shops usually have one thing in common. They’ve already figured out how to keep their best people.
Marketing only works as well as the people answering the phone and standing behind the counter when a stressed customer walks in. The best auto repair shop marketing in your market won’t matter if Steady Eddie walks out the door because nobody told him he mattered.
If you’re comparing auto repair shop marketing companies, look for the best agency for your shop, one that treats retention as part of growth. Good marketing amplifies good leadership. It can’t replace it. When you’re ready for a strategy that supports the team you’ve worked hard to keep, book a free discovery call with us.